Mediation


Mediation and Arbitration

Isaacs Odinocki LLP offers specialized mediation and private arbitration services for insurance coverage disputes, drawing on decades of experience advising insurers and policyholders on complex insurance matters.

Insurance coverage disputes often involve difficult questions of policy interpretation, competing legal positions and significant financial exposure.

Our mediators and arbitrators, Arie Odinocki and Marc D. Isaacs, bring a practical understanding of these issues and the commercial considerations that influence their resolution.

We offer two complementary approaches to resolving coverage disputes: mediation, providing an independent and constructive forum for negotiated settlement, and fast-track private arbitration, offering parties a timely and efficient alternative to conventional arbitration proceedings.

Arie Odinocki and Marc D. Isaacs


Our Services

Insurance Coverage Mediation

We provide an independent, balanced and constructive forum in which parties can explore settlement and work toward a mutually acceptable resolution.

Our mediation services are tailored to insurance coverage disputes, including questions of policy interpretation, exclusions, duties to defend and indemnify, allocation of defence costs, and other complex coverage issues.

Drawing on extensive experience in insurance law and litigation, our mediators assist parties in identifying the central issues, assessing their respective positions and exploring practical settlement options.

Our objective is to facilitate meaningful negotiations and help parties resolve disputes without the cost, delay and uncertainty of continued litigation.

Fast-Track Private Arbitration

A timely alternative to conventional arbitration proceedings

Conventional court proceedings can involve substantial delays, with parties often waiting a year or longer for a hearing after commencing the process. For insurance coverage disputes involving discrete legal or factual issues, such delays can be particularly costly and disruptive.

Our fast-track private arbitration service offers an efficient alternative. Subject to the parties completing their exchange of materials and any necessary cross-examinations, an arbitration hearing before Arie Odinocki or Marc D. Isaacs can generally be scheduled within 45 days of the filing of materials, with a written arbitral award issued within 30 days following the conclusion of the hearing and receipt of any final submissions.

Our Fast-Track Commitment

  • 45 Days to Hearing: Arbitration hearings can generally be scheduled within 45 days of the filing of materials, subject to completion of necessary procedural steps.
  • 30 Days to Written Award: A written arbitral award will be issued within 30 days following the conclusion of the hearing and receipt of any final submissions.

Our approach emphasizes focused proceedings, proportionate procedural requirements and timely adjudication. The process can be tailored to the nature and complexity of the dispute, whether it involves a discrete question of policy interpretation or a more substantial coverage controversy.

Private arbitration provides parties with the opportunity to have their dispute determined by an experienced insurance coverage lawyer, through a process designed to minimize unnecessary delay and expense.


Our Mediators and Arbitrators


Arie Odinocki

Arie Odinocki

Arie Odinocki is the Managing Partner of Isaacs Odinocki LLP and has practised insurance law for over 25 years. He leads the firm’s insurance coverage practice and regularly advises Canadian and international insurers on complex coverage disputes involving commercial liability, property and automobile insurance.

Arie is the editor of Ontario Insurance Law & Commentary, published by LexisNexis, and has been recognized annually in The Best Lawyers in Canada for Insurance Law since 2020. He brings to mediation and arbitration a thorough understanding of insurance law, a practical approach to dispute resolution and an appreciation of the interests of all parties.

Marc D. Isaacs

Marc D. Isaacs

Marc D. Isaacs is a founding partner of Isaacs Odinocki LLP and has practised law for over 30 years. His extensive litigation practice encompasses insurance coverage, commercial disputes, professional liability, transportation and maritime law. Marc is a former Adjunct Professor at the University of Toronto Faculty of Law and is ranked Band 1 by Chambers and Partners. Recognized for his expertise in complex insurance and commercial matters, Marc brings to mediation and arbitration a wealth of litigation experience, sound judgment and a pragmatic approach to resolving disputes. His broad experience enables him to assist parties in navigating difficult legal and factual issues and finding practical solutions.

Arie’s Availability

Available
Booked
Partially Booked
Unavailable
On Hold
MTWTFSS
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30

Marc’s Availability

Available
Booked
Partially Booked
Unavailable
On Hold
MTWTFSS
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30

Availability and Scheduling

Please consult the individual calendars above for the availability of Arie Odinocki and Marc D. Isaacs. To arrange a mediation or arbitration, or to inquire about scheduling and procedural arrangements, please contact:

Rachael Bruce (Office Manager)
416.318.0149 | rachael@iolaw.ca

Calendar availability is indicative and all dates must be confirmed with our office. Fast-track arbitration timelines are subject to the parties’ agreement, completion of necessary procedural steps and the availability of the selected arbitrator.